Resource centre for ZX Spectrum games
      using Manic Miner and Jet Set Willy game engines

 

 

	Previous message		Next message
	Previous in thread		Next in thread

 

 

Message: 5595

Author: dunny291073

Date: 25/02/2006

Subject: Re: Quirky features debate (or should I say war)

 

In manicminerandjetsetwilly@yahoogroups.com, Visa-Valtteri Pimiä wrote:

At least UMM is playable even without any knowledge of "quirky
features", with a bit of luck and experimentation. I myself know
little about the said features, and I almost never remember any of
them while playing, but I still seem to be able to complete even the
trickiest screens people have designed. I just try to be adventorous
and not always try the obvious thing first.

That, I think, is my main problem with this game - presentation issues
aside.

I wouldn't mind if the game was bloody hard to get through simply
because I didn't know the bugs to be exploited - but this one makes it
sooo damned hard.

If you don't know the way through, you've got about a minute or two to
figure it out before one of your lives goes out the window due to the
rather strict "air" limit. More than a couple of goes, and you're back
to the start which means that you have to wait through the first
black/text screen, run through to the bar, then try again.

Using an implementation like that doesn't require brains - it requires
prior knowledge, and if you don't have it then you're punished
severely. You've no real time when you get to the first screen to
ponder the layout, and try things, and solve the puzzle. You either
know the solution, or you die. A lot of other people are finding that
to be a real turn-off.

Tbh, I'd far rather than someone had developed an engine capable of
doing all these extra tricks more smoothly, and still managed to keep
the feel of JSW/MM in the way the characters moved and so on. That
would have been a far better way of pushing the genre.

If I were after a flamewar, I wouldn't keep on at the game to see what
else is on offer - I'd have left it when I binned it the first time.

D.

 

 

	Previous message	Back to the Yahoo! Archive home page	Next message
	Previous in thread		Next in thread